Sabremetrics is a concept that came about in the mid-20th century from statisticians such as Earnshaw Cook and Bill James. It is the analytical approach to quantifying talent through in-game activity in baseball.

The concept was utilized famously by Billy Beane to rebuild the Oakland Athletics, which coined the term Moneyball.

The principle is pretty simple. Most big time free-agents get picked up because of concepts like batting average, but this is a completely flawed metric according to Sabremetrics, because who cares about how often they hit the ball, you should care how many runs they can score.

Teams that use Sabremetrics look to use math to identify personnel that can be had cheaply to build a cohesive unit, rather than go about the route of the large market teams, and simply build through big names in free agency. A similar approach has been taken by the Patriots in the NFL.

Businesses can use this concept as well, because at the end of the day every action that makes money comes from a few core places:

1)   KPIs = Profits , it really is that simple. Every lead you get you get paid X, every widget you sell you get paid Y. Each visitor you get leads to Z leads so on and so forth. The actions worth their way down to the employee level, and through analytical practice you can figure out how much money a single employee will yield based on productivity.

2)   Knowledge Base: There are simply some things that are more valuable to know than others in any market. In software today PHP developers with strong database skills are in demand.  Knowledge base is not the same as having a degree.

3)   Cultural Fit: This one is tough, and completely subjective, but for me it also may be the most important.

Here is the raw truth:

CopyPress almost completely refuses to acquire talent, we instead opt to cultivate talent.

This isn’t a humblebrag. In fact, I wish we could go out and grab people at a high rate and just plug them in, we can’t.

Let’s first define acquired talent. To me it is someone with a large amount of experience and extensive resume looking to move to the next step in their career.

By comparison cultivated talent is a person with a thinner resume, and is looking to begin their career.

At first we too the cultivated talent approach because we simply couldn’t afford the high price tag of acquired talent. We talked to many people at different positions, but it simply wasn’t economical for us.

Since that point it has become a systematic necessity. One I didn’t even identify until we recently brought in a few highly trained individuals whom we simply couldn’t find a fit for.

The reality for us is that our system works, and works well. We do pay well once our team gets past the entry level, but they have to pay their dues, and be able to grind through our system, which has a heavy focus on the three concepts above.


At CopyPress we break everything down into granular KPIs to see how profitable every revenue earning employee is. This in itself is an issue because how do you approach KPIs for non-revenue generating employees, i.e. bookkeepers. KPIs can be a measure of stewardship as well (what they save you instead of what they make you.)

A great example for us is our standard entry-level position at CopyPress, the Connector. A Connector is paid $13 an hour to manage relationships between publishers and creatives. They utilize 100% organic methods to find new publishers and help them get content from our creatives that will maximize traffic. A Connector is the prototypical content marketer. They must understand outreach, content, and audience.

Connectors serve several key roles for us:

1)   They are helping us quantify the data we have in our software set.

2)   They are helping us build a large inventory of publishers our software and enterprise clients can use for native advertising

3)   They are helping us improve our creative marketplace and training

Despite all of these very different roles and tasks we found one KPI that can help us see how well a Connector is doing; new publishers contacted per day.

At the core of everything a Connector does is publisher connections. A low number of new publisher contacts can mean:

1)   A connector isn’t managing time well

2)   A connector is going to produce a low number of new relationships

3)   A connector does not understand our data mining system

4)   A connector is having trouble managing ongoing relationships

Figuring out core KPIs to gauge your staff on is important. Without it you are flying blind in terms of employee value, and this is where simply “liking” an employee can cause major tactical issues.

Knowledge Base

 Knowledge > degrees.

This is 100% a motto to live by for CopyPress. For very skilled positions such as development we always run through a contractor stage with a new employee to test a project. I really don’t care what your resume says I want to see what you know.

Further I want to know what you are willing to learn. Some of the best people we have are self-taught on our projects, and I will take this person over someone using poor experience from past employment.

For 80% of the positions we hire for we train within CopyPress. Even on our contractor level we train, and this is simply because we know our system works, and knowledge is power. For these positions I look for core elements to serve as a foundation, but nothing in particular.

For this 80% our KPIs and culture guide our gauge of talent, but we are looking for people with broad knowledge such as creative writing, editing, public relations, etc.

Cultural Fit

Every company’s culture is unique.

I read a great essay recently about how a cultural fit simply means adding to the status quo, and that is a great read on the situation. The reason this is not the case for us is because we live and die by accountability from our KPI obsession. However, if this was not the case we would just hire a bunch of people we want to hangout with.

Our culture is guided by some core principles:

1)   Humility

2)   Community

3)   The Customer Always Comes First

4)   Commitment to Learning and Testing

5)   Quality Above Profits

6)   Impossible Does Not Exist

7)   Our Team is Our Family

Based on these ideals I have found a great number of people are true fits for our system, but three distinct types of people seem to excel for us.

1)   Applicants with an athletic background

2)   Applicants with a musical background

3)   Applicants with a military background

4)   Applicants with extensive volunteer experience

This isn’t to say this is the case with all of our amazing team.  Kyle Zipp, one of our Product Managers, has come from none of these places. However, I have found amazing people from these areas more than not. My theory is that with each you are trained to strive for more, work within a team, and be willing to put the good of all above the good of one.

When I sit down and look at a resume I scan for hints at these concepts. These type of applicants intrigue me more than fancy schools and degrees.

The Importance of the System

I think it is important to note that you can find all of the awesome talent in the world, but if the system is flawed you will fail.

Our system works, because it is based on accountability.

1)   We hire based on knowledge base and cultural fit.

2)   We put the individuals through training and a strict 90 day trial

3)   We analyze KPIs

4)   Based on results we either part ways or put you on a two year growth plan

When we recently conducted interviews with some outside talent I had to make a tough decision to stick to this system or make concessions. We stuck to it. It may have cost us some talent, but what we are finding through this experiment in organizational strategy is that putting the whole ahead of the individual is delivering surprising results.

I strongly believe you couldn’t just begin to hire cheap employees that used to play basketball in high school and look to grow a profitable company from it. However, I will tell you that if you can strike the right balance of analytical talent measurement and systematic talent development you will be able to crush your operating costs comparable to your competition. But if you don’t hire the kid that played high school basketball send him my way.

By Jeremy Schoemaker

Jeremy "ShoeMoney" Schoemaker is the founder & CEO of ShoeMoney Media Group, and to date has sold 6 companies and done over 10 million in affiliate revenue. In 2013 Jeremy released his #1 International Best selling Autobiography titled "Nothing's Changed But My Change" - The ShoeMoney Story. You can read more about Jeremy on his wikipedia page here.

22 thoughts on “Build a Successful Business by Not Acquiring Talent”
  1. Hit this to a tee! People so often make the mistake of hiring a CEO because they think they need on when really all they need is a core team that can work together and get the job done.

  2. Great post! I think a lot of employers get this wrong as I do not have a college degree but I do have experience and I do have eagerness to learn and be open minded

    1. Good point, or employers ignore fresh graduates because they don’t have experience…thats what I want!!

  3. Seems like you have the hiring process figured out. I know a lot of companies do not at all and this is where it hurts them the most. Calculating someones worth to the company. Dont be afraid to firre

  4. Loved the movie Moneyball such a great flick with Ben Aflek. What a great concept that was and man was Billy smart with his numbers game

  5. This is where a lot of companies have problems. They go to recruiters hoping for the best and they are expected to pay 6 figures. Hire those that have less experience for a cheaper cost and mold them

    1. You’ll find out in most cases that you would’ve spent almost same amount in Hiring or Training. When you compare the time involved in both cases and not forgetting the making of PROFIT, I’ll prefer hiring.

  6. fabulous post! I really think you got it nailed down as to what you are looking for. I think a lot of companies miss that because they know they need to hire someone but dont know what they need

  7. I truly believe that cultural fit is very important. Hiring someone that does not have the same values as the company will bit the employer in the ass. they may be smart but in the end a pot stirrer.

  8. Great post! Very structured and disciplined way of creating your team.

    Thanks again!

  9. This is one of the best posts in awhile on this site!!! Loved it David, hope to see more from you in the future.

  10. Ahhhh I had always heard of SteelCast, nice to be able to put a name to a face now.

  11. I worked for a .com that had a slight grasp on this, they had the right idea, but as time went by I noticed that once the training was done and there were people adequately trained within the company to lead others down similar paths, management became lost and did not know what to do with them..the turnover became high for managers very quickly.

  12. ‘Build a Successful Business by Not Acquiring Talent’ – ShoeMoney Blog | Shoe in money says:

    […] Build a Successful Business by Not Acquiring Talent […]

  13. ‘Build a Successful Business by Not Acquiring Talent’ – ShoeMoney Blog | Work With Marcel Schmidt says:

    […] Build a Successful Business by Not Acquiring Talent […]

  14. I’ve been working with Dave and Copypress for over 6 months. Even the low level account people I talked to frequently have drive. If they don’t know the answer they’ll find it out for me and learn.

    I always picture Copypress is the new kid in high school. He’s hungry, works hard and soon enough he’ll be a champ and steal your girlfriend.

  15. If you want to build successful business you do not need talent. Everything is about good idea, strategy and hard work!

  16. Do not be afraid to take calculated risks. Too many small business owners worry more about what can go wrong instead of what can go right. All great leaders have failed, but learned what went wrong and corrected their mistakes. I like this phrases. In other words the content of the article is all positive and it is a great start of people would get a chance to read this.

  17. Hey just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The text in your article seem to be running off the screen in Ie.
    I’m not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with browser compatibility but I thought I’d post to let you know.
    The design and style look great though! Hope you get the problem resolved soon.


Comments are closed.